Your post will be moved lower in News Feed Facebook

Facebook has been steadily rolling out updates to Facebook Groups aimed at giving admins better ways to manage and moderate their online communities. Recently, this has included a combination of product releases — like access to automated moderation aids and alerts about heated debates — as well as new policies aimed at keeping Groups in check. Today, Facebook says it’s introducing two other changes. It will now enforce stricter measures against Group members who break its rules and it will make some of its removals more transparent, with a new “Flagged by Facebook” feature.

Specifically, Facebook says it will begin to demote all Groups content from members who have broken Facebook’s Community Standards anywhere across its platform. In other words, bad actors on Facebook may see the content they share in Groups downranked, even if they haven’t violated any of that Groups’ rules and policies.

By “demoting,” Facebook means it will show the content shared by these members lower in the News Feed. This is also called downranking and is an enforcement measure Facebook has used in the past to penalize content it wanted less of in News Feed — like clickbait, spam or even posts from news organizations.

In addition, Facebook says these demotions will get more severe as the members accrue more violations across Facebook. Because Facebook algorithms rank content in News Feed in a way that’s personalized to users, it could be difficult to track how well such demotions may or may not be working going forward.

Facebook also tells us the demotions currently only apply to the main News Feed, not the dedicated feed in the Groups tab where you can browse posts from your various Groups in one spot.

The company hopes this change will reduce members’ ability to reach others and notes it joins existing Groups penalties for rule violations that include restricting users’ ability to post, comment, add new members to a group or create new groups.

Another change is the launch of a new feature called “Flagged by Facebook.”

Image Credits: Facebook

This feature will show Group admins which content has been flagged for removal before it’s shown to their broader community. Admins can then choose to remove the content themselves or review the content to see if they agree with Facebook’s decision. If not, they can ask for a review by Facebook and provide additional feedback as to why they believe the content should remain. This could be helpful in the case of automated moderation errors. By allowing admins to step in and request reviews, they could potentially protect members ahead of an unnecessary strike and removal.

The feature joins an existing option to appeal a takedown to the Group admins, when a post is found to violate Community Standards. Instead, it’s about giving admins a way to be more proactively involved in the process.

Unfortunately for Facebook, systems like this only work when Groups are actively moderated. That’s not always the case. Though Groups may have admins assigned, if they decide to stop using Facebook or managing the Group but don’t add another admin or moderator to take over, their Group can plunge into chaos — particularly if it’s larger. One group member of a sizable group with over 40,000 members told us their admin had not been active in the group since 2017. The members know this and some will take advantage of the lack of moderation to post anything they want at times.

This is just one example of how Facebook’s Groups infrastructure is still largely a work-in-progress. If a company was building a platform for private groups from scratch, policies and procedures — like how content removals work, or the penalty for rule-breaking, for instance — wouldn’t likely be years-later additions. They would be foundational elements. And yet, Facebook is just now rolling out what ought to have been established protocols for a product that arrived in 2010.

Your Facebook News Feed has changed dramatically over recent years. Whereas in the past you’d be able to see what friends and family have been doing, in chronological order, your Facebook News Feed may displaying the sort of content that’s designed to make people angry.

This is one of the major points of contention in the Facebook whistleblower case, with former Facebook executive Frances Haugen saying the social network’s algorithm pushes toxic group content, placing this at the top of your News Feed. The reason? To keep you engaged and make you stay on Facebook longer, so the social network can serve you ads.

Lawmakers are concerned, with many saying they think Facebook users should have the option to disable this automated ranking system. It is the subject of a bill that’s just entered the House of Representatives, which states that social media companies shouldn’t rely on algorithms to govern what you see.

A report in the Washington Post shows why Facebook would be reluctant to turn off ranking completely. One internal report describes how when people can turn off the algorithm, they spend less time on their News Feed, and post and interact less. They’ll eventually log into Facebook less, and maybe even consider deleting Facebook.

There’s no doubt about it—less engagement is bad news for Facebook, which relies on revenue from advertising. The social network has also been struggling to attract younger users; it can’t afford for its base to shrink.

MORE FROMFORBES ADVISOR

Best Travel Insurance Companies

Amy Danise

Editor

Best Covid-19 Travel Insurance Plans

Amy Danise

Editor

Taking this into account, it certainly makes sense that Facebook banned the developer of the browser extension that allows people to get rid of their News Feed, Unfollow Everything in October.

The ad based and data hungry profit model is also one of the reasons why a Facebook-led Metaverse could be such a privacy nightmare. 

The Facebook setting you really should change

You might not be aware of this, but you can change your Facebook news feed to simply display your most recent updates by going to the bar on the left side of your News Feed and selecting Most Recent in the Settings. The bad news—it only works while you are logged in.

In general, by changing your preferences for Top Posts, you can also take back a bit of control over what and whose posts you see. Once logged into Facebook, go to Settings & Privacy > News Feed Preferences. There is a setting in there called Manage Favorites, which will allow you to add friends and pages you want to be prioritized in your News Feed.

It’s not perfect, and it’s not a catch-all solution, but it does help to take back a bit of control over your Facebook feed, and actually see posts from people and groups you want to follow. It’s therefore a good idea to change this setting now.

What would cause your post to appear less on the Facebook news feed?

How do I get my Facebook news feed back to normal?

How do I get my post to the top of News Feed?

What is Facebook lower feed?